Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!)

I LOVE a Frosty from Wendy’s, and I LOVE Pumpkin Pie…why not combine the two! Heaven = this Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe)!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty

I don’t know if there was any better treat as a kid than french fries dipped in a Wendy’s Frosty. (Side note: If you haven’t tried that…YOU HAVE TO. Just trust me) Anyway…regular frosties are great…but Autumn baking calls for everything to be made with Pumpkin. So I present to you my new creation of heaven in a glass…AKA the Pumpkin Pie Frosty!! This copycat variation of a classic sweet treat is SO delicious, and so perfect for this cooler weather we are about to experience! (fingers crossed on that part!)

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

I know I’m coming in hot on the fall flavors…but I just couldn’t wait to get started with everything pumpkin season. Fall is my very favorite season. It’s when we got married, when I can finally start wearing cardigans again, and when we can dress Scout up in all kinds of costumes. It’s a great time of year. Help me welcome Autumn the right way by trying these Pumpkin Pie Frosties for yourself!!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

I did a lot of researching to find the perfect Frosty recipe. The secret to this magic copycat recipe is sweetened condensed milk! It makes the shake extra frosty-like. I can’t wait to try it with other flavors!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

I’m not sure how this Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) will pair with fries, but I’m excited to find out!

I have a feeling it might be a new tradition!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!

Enjoy! (And thank you for putting up with my “celebrating Fall at the earliest possible moment” mentality!)

See the recipe card below for details on how to make this copycat Pumpkin Pie Frosty. Enjoy!

 

If you like this recipe, try these other easy pumpkin dessert recipes:

0 from 0 votes
Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe!) I LOVE going to Wendy's for a Frosty...and I love Pumpkin Pie...LET'S COMBINE THE TWO!
Pumpkin Pie Frosty
Total Time
30 mins
 
I LOVE a Frosty from Wendy's, and I LOVE Pumpkin Pie...why not combine the two! Heaven = this Pumpkin Pie Frosty (Copycat Recipe)!
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: frosty, pumpkin
Servings: 2
Calories: 1081 kcal
Author: Becky Hardin
Ingredients
  • 7 oz. sweetened condensed milk half of a can
  • 1 cup pumpkin puree
  • 8 oz. tub Cool Whip
  • 1 3/4 cup heavy cream
  • 3/4 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
Instructions
  1. Combine condensed milk, pumpkin, cool whip, and pumpkin pie spice in your ice cream makers frozen bowl. Use a spoon to stir and combine. It doesn't have to be completely combined, but as much as possible.
  2. Turn on your ice cream maker and pour in the cream as it spins.
  3. Let it turn for about 30 minutes, or until it is the consistency that you want.
  4. Top with more pumpkin pie spice or whipped cream as desired!
  5. Enjoy!
Nutrition Facts
Pumpkin Pie Frosty
Amount Per Serving
Calories 1081 Calories from Fat 774
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 86g 132%
Saturated Fat 53g 265%
Cholesterol 319mg 106%
Sodium 211mg 9%
Potassium 776mg 22%
Total Carbohydrates 70g 23%
Dietary Fiber 3g 12%
Sugars 58g
Protein 13g 26%
Vitamin A 447.8%
Vitamin C 10.9%
Calcium 45.4%
Iron 11.3%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

Did you make this recipe?

Use the tag #thecookierookie when posting a photo of your recipe, and make sure to follow The Cookie Rookie on Instagram!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments

Gerry @ Foodness Gracious
Fantastic idea and love those straws!
Krista @ Joyful Healthy Eats
I mean... would it be wrong for me to just lick the side of that glass. The frosty is dripping down the side... I would just be cleaning it up! :) hehe LOVE this Becky!
Jessica @ A Kitchen Addiction
These look incredible! Can't wait to try one!
Cristina @ I Say Nomato
Ohhhh wow! I'm so excited for fall, these frosties are perfect! (And you are right, fries dipped in frosties are THE BEST!)
    Becky Hardin
    Thanks Cristina! And I'm glad you're on the fry in the frosty bandwagon :)
Erin @ Texanerin Baking
I was wondering about the green color of these when I saw them on FB. Cool glasses! And even better Frosties. Love that you went and added pumpkin. :)
    Becky Hardin
    Ha I know...the glasses! They were so much greener in the pics than I thought they'd be lol!
Beth
Send me your backdrops, those little metal coasters/plates and a frosty in a box and I'll be happy forever! You rock friend!
    Becky Hardin
    Ha!!! I have some items you have that I'll swap you those things for gladly!! lol
Des @ Life's Ambrosia
I am so ready for all things pumpkin! And dipping fries into milkshakes has been one of my favorite guilty pleasures since I was a teenager. I am all over this!
Holly @ 3 Yummy Tummies
These look delicious Cardigan Queen!! Oh crap...I have to go get a frosty now. I don't know about the fry dipping situation though...LOL!
Nancy [email protected]
My family thinks it is crazy when I dip my fries into my frosty!! I love it! I am intrigued by this pumpkin pie flavor and definitely want to give it a try!
Maryanne @ the little epicurean
Old habits die hard. I still dip my fries into my chocolate frosty. I think I'll have to make sweet potato fries to eat with this pumpkin pie frosty! :)
Let's Work Together!

We would love to discuss collaborating for unique recipe development, professional food photography, brand ambassadorship, and so much more. Get in touch for stats and rates. Let’s chat!

FREE EBOOK + Never Miss a Post!

Join our mailing list for all the easiest and most delicious recipes! Claim your FREE EBOOK, Favorite Easy Chicken Dinners!

    find more delicious recipes:

Get your FREE ebook

FAVORITE EASY CHICKEN DINNERS

favorite chicken recipes ebook free

and join our community of over 100,000 subscribers!

No, thanks!