Homemade Dog Treats Recipe (Peanut Butter Dog Treats)

Homemade Dog Treats are the best way to show your pet that you love them like family! These Homemade Peanut Butter Dog Treats are an easy dog biscuit recipe that your fur baby would request every week if they could. If you’ve wondered How To Make Dog Treats, it’s much easier than you think. Your dog deserves these homemade treats and will be so excited! 

dog treats with text overlay: peanut butter dog treats

Homemade Dog Treats

Your dog deserves Homemade Dog Treats! And they’re going to absolutely love these fun Peanut Butter Dog Treats.

Homemade Dog Treats are so simple and easy! I’ve been doing the blog for over a year now and Scout has been by my side for every recipe. She gets to sample some, but for the most part, she only gets to enjoy the smells. But she always stays close, smiles for the camera, and cuddles with me while I write the posts.

She’s such a good girl, so I thought it was about time I made something just for her. I finally learned how to make dog treats! And let me tell you, this dog biscuit recipe was a BIG hit. These Homemade Peanut Butter Dog Treats are a hit each and every time she smells them baking!

Show your pup how much you love them by baking up some fresh homemade dog treats!

This Homemade Dog Treats Recipe is so easy to make, and your pup will absolutely love them. Show some love with these tasty Peanut Butter Dog Treats!

homemade dog treats laid out on a baking sheet

Peanut Butter Dog Treats Recipe

These Homemade Dog Treats bake up just like Scout likes them, crunchy and delicious!

Remember, we are making these dog biscuits for DOGS, not humans. But the best part?? They smell good! The smell of peanut butter is so much better than the scent of milkbones! I don’t have to gag or make her eat these on the porch.

These dog biscuits are people safe just in case your baby finds one and eats it (No? Just mine??). These homemade dog treats are cheap, easy, and your dog will love you even more once you’ve made them! :)

step by step photos how to make homemade dog treats

How to Make Dog Treats at Home

I made these Homemade Dog Treats with peanut butter, but you could substitute other pet friendly flavors. Sweet potato or pumpkin would make great substitutions!

The dough for these dog biscuits is very firm and sticky, but don’t let that scare you! You’re making it right! I rolled my dough to about half an inch thick before cutting out the shapes, and they turned out great. The dough only rises slightly, so you can cut out almost any shape and it will hold.

I chose some small Christmas shapes as well as my adorable “Scout” cookie cutter from Etsy. You can find it HERE. Scout was so excited to eat her homemade peanut butter dog treats! The same company on Etsy makes customized Dog Cookie Cutters with all sorts of breeds. You know you need one. 

homemade dog biscuits

Gift Idea: Homemade Dog Biscuits

These homemade dog treats make a great (and CHEAP AND EASY) gift for your favorite dog lover.

If Christmas is coming up or any need for a homemade gift, this Dog Biscuit Recipe is such a thoughtful and easy way to show love to those around you. Loving on someone’s pet is always the way to their heart. Pet’s are like children! They’re one of the family.

Wrap them in a cute ribbon or store them in an adorable (CHEAP) jar from Hobby Lobby. You’ll be the star for sure.

Is peanut butter safe for dogs?

There has been some discussion on whether or not peanut butter is safe for dogs. I always do research before even thinking about feeding Scout something that could be toxic…she’s my girl!!

Peanut butter is actually a healthy food for dogs, containing vitamins and healthy fats. As always, moderation is key. Dogs can be allergic to things just like people. If you feel uncomfortable using peanut butter, other great alternatives would be pumpkin or sweet potato. Let me know if you have questions!

Can you use all purpose flour in peanut butter dog treat recipes?

Yes, you can. Just like the answer about peanut butter above, some dogs can be allergic to things like gluten found in regular flour. Whole wheat flour can have some more nutrients which is always great, or you can use an alternative flour like coconut flour. I always recommend letting your dog sample a small amount before giving them lots of treats, because dogs can be allergic to anything, just like people!

How long can you keep this Dog Biscuit Recipe?

It’s best to seal these Dog Treats in an airtight container and store in the fridge. They will stay good in the fridge for up to 2 months, or you can freeze them for up to 8 months! This recipe is awesome to make in bulk and reward your pup for great behavior or for just being themselves from time to time. They do a lot for us and they deserve it!

dog treats wrapped in ribbon

homemade dog biscuits laid next to christmas lights

Scout looks like she approves of herself in cookie form, don’t you agree? She’s pretty darn cute if I do say so myself. The best dog ever deserves the Best Homemade Dog Treats ever. She loves Peanut Butter Dog Treats more than she loves me…I’m pretty sure.

Homemade Dog Treats are the best way to show your pet that you love them like family! These Homemade Peanut Butter Dog Treats are a Dog Biscuit Recipe that your fur baby would request every week if they could. If you've wondered How To Make Dog Treats, it's much easier than you might have thought. Your dog deserves these homemade treats and will be so excited!

dog looking at dog biscuit on the floor

She loves her peanut butter dog biscuits

I am quite aware that I’ve included too many pictures but HOW CAN I NOT when Scout was being such a good model. And how she was practicing this amount of self control is beyond me. She was richly rewarded in lots of Peanut Butter Dog Treats and lucky for her, I will be making these again and again and again.

dog with red ribbon tied around it

dog with homemade dog biscuit

I hope your fur baby loves these homemade dog treats as much as Scout does! 

Watch the video for details! Find a Customized Cookie Cutter for your dog’s breed and see below for how to make Peanut Butter Dog Treats!

Be sure to check out our other favorite pet treat recipes:

Did you make this recipe?

Use the tag #thecookierookie when posting a photo of your recipe, and make sure to follow The Cookie Rookie on Instagram!

Leave a Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Sandy Bruce
    becky gall hardin
    April L Catey
      Trish Dones
Janet Sonneman
Lori Viereckl
      Jody hartley
    becky gall hardin
Brigette Britton
    becky gall hardin
Nikki Darkforest
    becky gall hardin
    becky gall hardin
      izzy's mom
        Doodlebug's mommy
        Becky Hardin
          Becky Hardin
        Becky Hardin
      Nancy Sawhill
    Mary Doris-Antonopoulos
      becky gall hardin
        Katrina Matt
          Becky Hardin
      Becky Hardin
        Becky Hardin
          Becky Hardin
          Robert P. Dean
      Sonya Wedge
        Becky Hardin
        teresa barroso
      Becky Hardin

5 Ingredient Recipes

Sign up for emails and get our 7 Day Guide to Cooking plus get our FREE ebook!



5 Ingredient Recipes Ebook Cover
No Thanks