Cookies and Cream Cookie Butter (Trader Joe’s Copycat Recipe)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

If you miss Trader Joe’s Cookies and Cream Cookie Butter, then I’ve got a treat for you! This copycat recipe is so easy. You’ll want to eat this cookie butter every day! 

graham cracker scooping out cookie butter

Any self-respecting Trader Joe’s addict has tried their Cookies and Cream Cookie butter. When I first saw it on the shelves, I knew I would be hooked. It’s the perfect dip or spread to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Why You Should Make This Cookies and Cream Cookie Butter

  • Cookies and Cream – I used Oreo’s to get the true cookies and cream flavor in this recipe and it is SO good.
  • So Easy! – This recipe couldn’t be easier to make. A quick dessert or sweet snack for dipping.
  • Trader Joe’s Copycat Recipe – If you ever had the Trader’s Joe’s Cookie and Cream Cookie Butter, this DIY version will make your day!

oreos in a blender

 

a jar of cookie butter in front of blender of oreos

What is Cookie Butter?

If you’ve never had cookie butter, then you’re missing out! It’s basically like peanut butter or any other spread, but it’s made with fine bits of cookie. Yum!

I consider it (especially this cookies and cream butter) like Nutella. It’s creamy, sweet, delicious, and easy to spread onto breads, but also works as a dip.

Copycat Trader Joe's Cookies and Cream Cookie Butter in a mason jar

top view of cookie butter

close up of cookie butter

Ingredients List

You don’t need much to make this cookies and cream cookie butter!

  • Oreos – It wouldn’t be cookies and cream without these!
  • Heavy Cream
  • Vegetable Oil
  • Unsalted Butter
  • Vegetable Shortening
  • Powdered Sugar
  • Vanilla Extract

a blendtec blender on a counter

How to Make Cookies and Cream Cookie Butter

Check the recipe card below for the full instructions. Here’s a quick overview of the cookie butter recipe.

  1. Chop/crush up the Oreos then mix with heavy cream and oil until it becomes a batter.
  2. Beat butter and shortening, then add in sugar and vanilla and combine until creamy.
  3. Place each mixture (the cookie side and then the cream side) into a jar or bowl.

Store it in the refrigerator for up to a week!

jar of cookie butter

jar of cookie butter in front of oreos and graham crackers

What to Eat with Cookie Butter

I absolutely love serving this cookie butter with graham crackers. The sweetness matches the flavor perfectly. Everyone in the room will devour it (so keep it hidden if you want it all for yourself). I’m not opposed to eating it by the spoonful either.

But you could also serve it with cookies (yes, more cookies!), or mix a spoonful into your bowl of ice cream. But don’t feel limited with this stuff. Try it on everything! Waffles and pancakes, fruit, toast, pretzels, churros, brownies. So much to try!

hand scooping out butter with graham cracker

graham cracker with cookies and cream cookie butter on it

Make this cookie butter ASAP and get to dipping. You won’t regret making it because it’s so easy and delicious. Yum!

More sweet desserts and snacks to try:

Did you make this recipe?

Use the tag #thecookierookie when posting a photo of your recipe, and make sure to follow The Cookie Rookie on Instagram!

Leave a Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Comments

Becky Hardin
Rosalinda
Alison DiLouie
Alison DiLouie
Becky Hardin
Diane Jackson
Becky Hardin
Lisa | Sweet and Savory Breads
Becky Hardin
Nagi @ RecipeTin Eats
Becky Hardin
Shelby @ Go Eat and Repeat
Kelsey Brown
Abby
Thomas Murphy
karen
Jennifer Cook
Rebecca G
Elizabeth F.
Krista
Denise Meechan
charul ajmera
Alexa
Cinda Brown
Marsha A
Marsha A
Chelsea B
Trica
Kylie @ FotV
Monica
Melissa
Melissa Nau
Colleen Fitzpatrick
Nick
BeckieLynn
denise z
Laurin Schisler
Michelle
Heather Duke
loyri halliburton
Jessica
marissa
Ali F
tamara
Janette Willis
Meredith
Chelsea
VANESSA
Ashley bauer
Tiffany H
Sarah
Dameon S
Nichol
Nichol
Camila Melody
Ashley
Ashley Naylor
Heather Gerber
Miriam
Carrie
Lisa Aliperti
Loren Morris
Deborah Balint
Dawn
Dana Truitt
Shelli Jones
chickie brewer
ginger
SA Matthews
Mel
Val Myers
Amary Chapman
Wendy Forbes
Judi MeElroy
Melissa Nelson
Jennifer Logan
Sherri Moore
Betty Hardin
Teresa
MarthaW
Jackie Kaufman
Betsy Barnes
Robn C
Susan M
candy
Karen D
Amanda Barrow
laura
Chris Whittington
Dawn Monroe
Tami
Jason
Sharida
Debbie M
Mallory S
Marion Maurer
Erin M.
jenny
Denise Stevens
Amanda Sakovitz
Laura
Ashante Diplock
DD
Tammy Dalley
Sheila Belveal
alicia szemon
Char Scott
Barbara D
Jocelyn
Amanda Heslop
Amber Current
Mary Prevost
Bridget M
michelle lee
Susan Scott
lisa
K
abby
mary atkinson
Rachel Turner
Jacki
Robin
Renee Sandoval
JoLynn
Diane F
Sandy
Jessica @ Sprinkle Some Sugar
Amy L
To a
Brittney
s.w
Melinda
Amy S.
Maggie C
Vicky
heather murray
Kelly
Amy C
Dijah W
Natalie Brown
rosalind
Marissa hogan
Becky Hardin
Margot C
Jeane Campbell
Matty Ice
Doug
Doug
Rust
Julie Kramer
Lyn M
Jennifer B
marshall
cassandra
Cindy
Birdiebee
Jessica
itzia
Renee
Tracy
Sylvia
Thomas
Kathi
Mellisa
Kim
Michelle S
Megan Marlowe
Marilyn Nawara
Jeffrey
Catherine
Becky Hardin
Andreas H
Emily West
Cristina O
Mae
Annette
Sara
Vicki D Kinsey
Bravo
Sara
Darlene
Tamara Davidson
Yocaret
Becky
Darlene
Jenn W
Jayne
Sarah D
Lisa
angela purdy
Christine
Robin New
Amy
Mariann
Lauren
Cheryl
Miranda R.
Jessica Lehmann
Jamie
Julie Henderson
Jen
Becky Hardin
Sara
Allison
Tom H.
Heather
Lisa Brown
valerie sobus
AlexisB
Monica G.
Charline
Renee F
Heather | girlichef
Amy C.
Leigh Anne Borders
Janelle
steve weber
Melanie | Melanie Makes
Ashley
Patricia @ Grab a Plate
Stefanie Hassan
Liz
Nina Lechowicz
Amy m
Pam A
Colleen Boudreau
Ashley Bree Perez
crissy
Kelly
Liz
Melissa L.
Maria Glenn
crissy
Nicole Dz
kimberly morgan
theresa krier
Kristy Marshall
Cydney Marshall
Cheryl
Rachael
Alison H.
Meg @ The Housewife in Training Files
LisaY
Amy @ A Healthy Life For Me
HS
Holly E
Rebecca
Jodi
Missy
alexandra robertson
Amy S.
Kacey @ The Cookie Writer
Jacqui Odell
Kalee Hall
Karen Koval
Sheena @ Hot Eats and Cool Reads
Brittany
Lynnette Lamance
Jennie
Becky Hardin
Becky Hardin
Becky Hardin
Diana
Deborah
Mary Beth
Karen gard
Stephanie
Angel S.
Lynn Erickson
Leanna Dreher
Jill T.
Amber Ashmore
Mary Helen Lawson
Natasha H.
paula
Candace Moore
Tina Robinson
Theresa Dinnocenzo
Jeanna
Una Walker
Paula L
Stephanie Phelps
Sylvia Anderson
Ana Martins
Dinah Makowsky
Andrea D.
MONICA
marshall reagan
Aishah M
Susie Gall

CONFIDENCE

in the kitchen

Get our newest recipes in your inbox PLUS our 7 day cooking guide. You'll also get our FREE ebook: Learning to Cook!

FREE

EBOOK

learn to cook ebook graphic
No Thanks