Best Potato Salad Recipe

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

This classic potato salad is seriously the best recipe you will try! Made with egg, it is wonderfully creamy and a must for any cookout this summer!

up close image of potato salad

No cookout is complete without a classic potato salad, it’s always a crowd pleaser! Creamy soft potatoes in a mayonnaise dressing, side dishes just don’t get much better!

Quick and easy to make, everyone will be asking you for this recipe!

Why this is the best potato salad recipe!

  • Flavorful: The potatoes are seasoned before and after cooking and the dressing has mustard, herbs and spices.
  • Soft and fluffy potatoes: Be sure to get my top tips how to cook the potatoes perfectly!
  • Versatile: This egg potato salad pairs wonderfully with so many mains, grilled meats, fish, chicken and all your BBQ favorites!

How to make classic potato salad

Be sure to scroll down for the full recipe!

  • Cook the potatoes in salted water with vinegar. Drain and season.
  • Mash half of the eggs with a fork.
  • Mix together the dressing ingredients.
  • Fold everything together.
classic potato salad in black bowl
overhead image of potato salad with egg in bowl

How long does it keep?

This salad will keep well in the fridge in a sealed container for up to 24 hours. It’s a great option for picnics and potlucks! Because there is mayonnaise in the salad, take care not to leave it at room temperature for more than 2 hours.

What are the best potatoes to use?

I like to use russet potatoes for my salad. They are starchy potatoes that get really nice and fluffy when cooked. If you don’t have russet, Yukon Gold or Idaho will both work well. It’s best to avoid waxy potatoes.

Do you need to peel the potatoes?

The choice is yours! If your potatoes are smaller with thin skins then you don’t have to peel them, and they add a nice color to the finished dish. Just give them a good wash. Feel free to peel them if you prefer!

potato salad with egg in bowl
potato salad recipe with wooden spoon

For the best potato salad

  • It is very important to season the potatoes with salt, vinegar and sugar while cooking and adding additional vinegar and salt to the potatoes while still hot.
  • Don’t cook the potatoes in already boiling water. Add them to cold water and bring everything to the boil together so that they cook evenly through.
  • Take care not to over or undercook the potatoes. They should be fork tender when you remove them from the water.
  • Let the potatoes cool before mixing them with the mayonnaise. If you add the mayonnaise to hot potatoes it can become quite oily.
potato salad recipe with wooden spoon

More Easy Potato Recipes

Did you make this recipe?

Use the tag #thecookierookie when posting a photo of your recipe, and make sure to follow The Cookie Rookie on Instagram!

Leave a Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating


Becky Hardin


in the kitchen

Get our newest recipes in your inbox PLUS our 7 day cooking guide. You'll also get our FREE ebook: Learning to Cook!



learn to cook ebook graphic
No Thanks