Margarita Pitcher Recipe Recipe - The Cookie Rookie®

I absolutely love to create delicious cocktail recipes for parties, and this big-batch Margarita pitcher recipe has been one of my favorites for years and years! I developed it with the help of my Mom, and we both agree it’s the best pitcher cocktail we’ve ever tried. I love serving these crowd-friendly margaritas at family functions and for groups of friends. It’s made with simple and fresh ingredients, and it’s utterly delicious. What I really love is that it’s scalable– I’ve made it for as few as 2 people and as many as 24. The recipe card will explain how to make it for a few or a lot!

I love this batch margarita pitcher recipe because it tastes fresh, isn’t too sweet, and it’s made with simple ingredients. It is super smooth, so watch out! It works great as a single serving, or as an entire pitcher. You’re going to love this!

What’s in my Margarita Recipe?

Cointreau: This orange liqueur is a staple in margaritas. I prefer Cointreau over triple sec, but either will work.
Lime Juice: Freshly squeezed lime juice is the key to a delicious margarita. Don’t use bottled lime juice; it just won’t taste the same!
Tequila: Choose a good-quality Reposado tequila (I find this is absolutely key!) for the smoothest, best-tasting margaritas.
Agave Syrup: Agave nectar is a great all-natural sweetener. Use more or less depending on your tastes.
Ice: Chills down individual servings and keeps them cool all day long.

Tips for Success

Batch these margaritas early in the day, but shake up individual drinks just before serving for the best taste!
I like to keep my tequila in the freezer to create the coldest margarita recipe possible with the least amount of ice. I don’t want to water this deliciousness down!
If you want an even fresher taste, you can add a splash of freshly squeezed orange juice!
These Margaritas are not very sweet. If you would like them sweeter, just add more agave syrup to taste.
If you want salted glass rims, cover the bottom of a small plate with margarita salt. Rub the rims of the glasses with a lime wedge, dip the rims in the margarita salt, and set the glasses upright to dry a tad before filling with ice.
It’s important to shake the margaritas before serving. Add 2-4 servings to a shaker with ice right before serving and repeat for each serving. Makes all the difference. Your guests will thank you!

How to Store

I store leftover pitcher margaritas tightly covered with plastic wrap in the refrigerator for up to 8 hours. Shake individual drinks over ice in a cocktail shaker just before serving. In the recipe card, you can find a link to my favorite shakers!

Serving Suggestions

I think that a pitcher of margaritas is the best easy cocktail for Cinco de Mayo celebrations. Serve them up with Baked Chicken Tacos, White Queso, Mexican Street Corn Dip, Chicken Nachos, or Homemade Tortilla Chips and Salsa.

How to Make a Margarita Pitcher (24 Servings) Step by Step

Mix the Margs: In 2-quart pitcher, combine 3 cups of Cointreau, 3 cups of freshly squeezed lime juice, 6 cups of Reposado Tequila, and 1 cup of Agave syrup. Keep the margarita mixture refrigerated until ready to serve.

stirring margarita mixture in a pitcher with a wooden spoon.

Prep the Glasses: When ready to serve, rim the glasses with salt (if desired) and fill each with ice.

Shake Individual Servings: Fill a cocktail shaker ¾ of the way with ice. Add enough prepared margarita mixture to the top of the ice. Cover tightly and shake vigorously 10-15 seconds. Pour into prepared glasses and serve immediately. Drain excess water from the shaker. Repeat for the additional servings, adding more ice as needed.

shaking individual margaritas in a cocktail shaker.

Garnish and Serve: Garnish with a lime wedge or wheel.

garnishing a margarita with a lime wedge.

More Margarita Recipes To Try

What is the 321 margarita rule?

An easy way to remember how to mix a classic margarita is to memorize the ratio 3-2-1: three parts tequila, two parts triple sec, and one part lime juice. I changed up the ratios a bit in this recipe, and I think it’s even better this way, but you be the judge!

How many people does this Margarita Pitcher Recipe serve?

I have written the recipe below for just 1 serving and also for 24 servings in a large pitcher. You decide if it’s worth sharing with friends. This is one I might just keep all to myself.

What is the best tequila?

When making margaritas, I always opt for one that isn’t the most expensive and isn’t the cheapest. You want a quality tequila that is smooth and well made, but there’s no reason to break the bank when you’re not sipping it straight. For these Pitcher Margaritas, I recommend using a Reposado Tequila which is typically smoother than a Blanco or Anejo Tequila. Once I made that change in this recipe, it made all the difference.

Are Triple Sec and Cointreau the same thing?

Cointreau is a brand of Triple Sec, so technically yes. Cointreau is a trusted brand from France and their Orange Liqueur is delicious! I find some Triple Sec has a bitter or fake taste, but not Cointreau.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

125 Comments

Inline Feedbacks

View all comments

ann

Posted on 5/3/2024

Do you need to do the “shake” part? I’m wondering for a big crowd how to get that accomplished?? Also, has anyone blended these? To make a “slush” margarita! Thanks for the help!